Monday, April 27, 2015

LMS Showdown: Google Classroom vs. Moodle

In my computer classes, I try to teach paperless as much as I can. I first started this practice when my school made Moodle available to teachers several years ago. I vividly remember being completely unsure of how this would go, and wondering how I'd teach paperlessly. Now I can't imagine having done it any other way, and I really don't miss piles of paper on my desk, in my bag, in my car, on my kitchen table...you get the idea.

I used Moodle for several years, mostly for 9th grade Digital Literacy--a Microsoft Office class. Although several of our teachers use Moodle now, I am the teacher that introduces students to it in 9th grade. Moodle can be daunting, visually, and a little scary for both teachers and students. Moodle has so many options and features that it can be a little cumbersome to work with, but it has a lot of options and features. Moodle will always be my first LMS love.

Google Classroom is a new feature in Google Apps for Education and I have been using it for a semester. Visually, Classroom is much more streamlined and easy on the eyes. It reminds me of a Facebook page, only without the ads, of course! A consequence of simple and streamlined though, is not as many options as Moodle.

Just recently Google Classroom added the ability to create posts/assignments and save them as a draft until you need them. A must for teachers who plan ahead. There are several features I still miss from Moodle such as the ability to group tasks and resources within a block/unit, and the ability to empty a course for a new year and/or copy a course to a new year. These features are not yet in Classroom.

Besides visually looking cleaner, Classroom has a really simple and easy-to-use interface. Both students and I find it easier to see what is assigned, when it is due, and what has been done. Giving students feedback is easier in Classroom. A huge advantage of Classroom is its seamless integration with Google Drive, if you use Drive for student assignments.

So what is my verdict? Well...it depends on what you want to do and how/what you teach. For my project-based 10th grade class, Google Classroom is my pick. But for classes with lots of assignments grouped by unit or chapter, I still prefer Moodle because of the way I can organize tasks and hide or show blocks at a time. If Google Classroom continues its improvements, however, I think it could become a powerhouse in the LMS arena.

I did not include in my review other popular LMS options such as Schoology and Edmodo because I have not actually used these with students. What LMS do you use? Do you like it? Why?

1 comment:

  1. Training and Learning are crucial for the growth and success of all organizations - big or small and across different industries. A Learning Management System streamlines learning and is put in place to manage the entire training process in an organization.learning' 'management' 'systems